Thursday, September 18, 2008

Why I won't support Obama or McCain


I don't have high expectations for political candidates. Google's corporate motto sums up my standard: "Don't be evil."

I'm neither a Democrat nor a Republican, neither liberal nor conservative. I'm just as orthodox a Catholic as I know how to be, and I can't seem to square that with the platforms of either major party. Perhaps such a "plague o' both your houses" position is naive or irresponsible, but it isn't born out of mere contrarianism. Everyone wants to belong, and it would be nice to have some political camp to call home.

So I'd like to be able to get behind Barack Obama or John McCain and feel hip and stylish or old and crotchety, respectively. They both seem like nice enough guys who generally want to do good. But I can't get past the fact that they both support causes that are intrinsically evil, like abortion and/or embryonic stem cell research.

It has always been obvious to me -- completely independent of any religious conviction -- that human life begins at the moment of conception, i.e., when a sperm fertilizes an egg. (If it doesn't begin then, when does it?) It has also always been obvious to me that it is always wrong to deliberately take the life of an innocent human being. (If that's not wrong, what is?)

Those two propositions, taken together, lead me to the conclusion that abortion and embryonic stem cell research are never morally acceptable, regardless of the circumstances.

Obama supports both abortion and ESCR; McCain supports the latter. Which leaves me hoping that the two senators either haven't given their positions on these issues much thought, or that they're both incredibly stupid. Because otherwise I can't escape the conclusion that both our candidates for the presidency are moral monsters. Let me explain.

If you accept the premise that murder is wrong, the only morally legitimate way I can see to support abortion or ESCR is to claim to know that human life does not begin at conception. But neither Obama nor McCain claims to know that, or even to believe it.

When Obama was asked at the Compassion Forum on April 18 whether he personally believed that life begins at conception, he said, "I don't presume to know the answer to that question." Now, either Obama was simply being insincere and was trying to appear humble while painting pro-lifers as presumptuous, or else he knowingly supports the destruction of what may or may not, for all he knows, be living human beings. I refer him to Boston College philosophy professor Peter Kreeft, who asks: If you're out in the woods hunting, and you hear a rustling in the bushes, and you're not sure whether it's a deer or your fellow hunter, what do you do? Don't shoot! If you honestly don't know whether a zygote or an embryo or a fetus is a living human being, Senator Obama, don't destroy it. That's at least criminal negligence, if not manslaughter.

McCain's moral inconsistency is perhaps even worse. At the Saddleback Forum on August 16, Rick Warren asked him at what point a baby is entitled to human rights. McCain immediately replied, to much applause, "At the moment of conception." So in supporting ESCR, McCain is endorsing the destruction of what he believes (correctly) to be living human beings with human rights. That's the definition of murder.

I understand that abortion and embryonic stem cell research are deeply personal, emotionally charged issues. But in any moral system worthy of the name, there are some things you just can't do, even in the worst circumstances, or with the best intentions. That our presidential candidates don't seem to understand this, and that they both employ such duplicitous and disingenuous rhetoric to obscure the reality of their positions, makes me fear for the future.

12 comments:

mikeg said...

Great post. I feel the same way.

Phil said...

I do not understand your position. You will never find a candidate with whom you agree on all issues. The only way for that to happen is to vote for yourself. Adults make choices based on what is the best available, not the ideal. I suggest you think long and hard about the Supreme Court appointments that will be made by Obama and McCain. If you want Roe v Wade overturned, then McCain is the obvious choice. The next president, in all likelihood, will have at least 2 Supreme Court appointments, not to mention dozens of Appellate Court appointments. Judicial appointments affect our society well after the president leaves office, and only McCain is on the right (if imperfect) track towards restoring a culture of life.

John Lewandowski said...

I believe that John McCain can be convinced to change his position on embryonic stem cell research. His running mate, Sarah Palin, opposes it, as does most of the base of his party.

Barack Obama, however, will never change his position on this issue. He supports it, Joe Biden supports it, the Democratic Party almost monolithically supports it, and they are not going to change their minds any time soon.

I look at it this way - either Obama or McCain is going to be the next president. When I acknowledge this reality, the choice becomes clear to me. We cannot vote for evil, but we can certainly vote for the lessening of evil.

Anonymous said...

To not vote would be a vote for Obama. This is the man who sat in the church of a "pastor" who spewed hatred for America for 20 yeara. He is also the man who voted four times in the Illinois Senate for infanticide. Mcain could be persuaded on embryonic stem cell research. Obama is just plain evil.

M. Swaim said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
M. Swaim said...

Bravo! Nicely posted.

I utterly disagree with the Supreme Court argument for supporting McCain. It stretches credulity to claim certainty that the same man whom John Kerry casually joked about choosing as a running mate, the same man who floated pro-aborts Lieberman and Ridge for his own running mate would pick justices that would overturn Roe v. Wade.

The fact of the matter is that the man is pro-life because he's a Republican. Don't get your culture of life hopes up too high.

Steve said...

Great post, Kevin. Couldn't agree more.

Malibu Michael Murphy said...

You people are the ones spewing hate!
You are so blinded by this one issue!

Anonymous said...

Hi there! Τhis is my fiгst сommеnt here sо I јuѕt wаnted to
gіvе a quick shοut out and tell you I tгuly enjoу rеaԁing through
your blog рostѕ. Can you suggеst any other blogѕ/websitеѕ/fοгums that сοver thе same topicѕ?
Thanks!

Feel free to ѕurf to my weblog: Used bucket trucks
my website > boom trucks

Anonymous said...

I feel thiѕ iѕ among thе ѕο much imрοrtant іnfо foг me.
And i'm glad reading your article. But should commentary on few normal things, The site style is ideal, the articles is truly nice : D. Excellent activity, cheers

Also visit my web blog ... bucket truck information
Feel free to surf my page - bucket trucks

Anonymous said...

Saved as а fаvoгіtе, I like youг
sіte!

Reviеω my blοg poѕt ... utility Bucket truck

Anonymous said...

Cool blog! Is your theme custom maԁe or
did уou ԁownlоad it from somеωhere?

A design like yοurs with а feω
simple tωеeks wοuld really mаke mу blog stand
out. Plеаse let me κnoω where you got your desіgn.
Manу thanks

Feel free to surf tо my blog: dallas seo company